
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL AND APPLIED PSYCHOANALYSIS. No. 4 (2026)Author — Anna Mikhaylovna Karpul, clinical, psychoanalytic, crisis, perinatal psychologist, practicing psychologist-psychotherapist, DPPG specialist, mediator, integrative supervisor in a multimodal approach, head of the regional branch of the Russian Association of Psychotherapists, specialist of the Russian Association of Psychotherapists, member of the European Association for Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy, Association of Specialists in Psychoanalytic Psychosomatics, International Association of Psychologists.Keywords: psychoanalysis, lie, truth, reality, ambiguity, origins, false self, true self, reality, fantasies, fiction, invention, inversion, deception, forgery, mask, illusion, self-deception, language, metaphor, distortion, falsification, surrogate, love in transference, scenarios, psychological defenses, repressed memories, splitting, multiplicity, unconscious, reproduction, communication, disappointment, striving for truth, experience, new experience, subjective truth, tolerance
The article examines the issues of the collision between two protagonists with falsehoods in the psychoanalytic process.
The course covers the core concepts of leading psychoanalysts regarding the true and false Self, reality versus fantasy, and the causes and meanings of the subject’s «embedded» falsehoods. It also explores the fundamental concepts of lies and truth, examining the scenarios in which the subject enacts deception. Particular attention is paid to the analyst’s perception of falsehood as a manifestation of normality within the therapeutic process, which helps create a foundation for transformation. Special focus is given to the pathology of lying.
The hypothesis advanced is that psychoanalysis is a method that works with falsehood both at the «entry and exit,» providing a space for deception where the subject strives to understand the truth by reconstructing (and distorting) themselves and their past in a bearable way. This offers the subject the opportunity to experience (I feel—therefore I live), and consequently, to discover new experiences. Psychoanalysis is a revolutionary tool through which the subject learns to continuously know themselves (and others through themselves) and their potential, rediscovering that they are not identical to their former Self. Only by creatively unfolding beyond their former form can the subject discover themselves, and this unfolding is possible when something new emerges at the intersection of lies and the quest for truth.
























